Do All Heirs Have to Agree to Sell Property?

When it comes to settling an estate, whether through probate or other legal proceedings, the question often arises: do all heirs have to agree to sell property? The answer isn’t always straightforward and can depend on various factors. In this blog post, we’ll delve into the intricacies of selling property as part of estate proceedings, the rights and responsibilities of heirs, and how to navigate this process effectively.

Understanding the Role of Executors and Administrators: 

Understanding the Role of Executors and Administrators

In most cases, an executor or administrator is appointed by the Surrogate’s Court to handle the estate of a deceased individual. The executor is typically an estate heir, as designated in the deceased’s will. However, administrators, who handle cases where there is no will, are usually the closest living relatives.

Selling Real Property During Estate Proceedings: 

One common question is whether all heirs must agree to sell property during probate. The truth is that the decision ultimately rests with the executor or administrator, who is tasked with managing the estate. In cases where the deceased’s debts outweigh their assets, the executor or administrator has the authority to sell real estate, even if some heirs object, to settle outstanding debts and satisfy creditors.

It’s important to note that while the law only requires approval from the executor or administrator, it’s advisable for them to consult with the heirs regarding the sale of the property. This communication helps to avoid potential disputes or accusations of misconduct by the executor for selling the property below market value, which could lead to legal consequences.

The Importance of Consent from Beneficiaries: 

To prevent misunderstandings and legal issues, beneficiaries should confirm their agreement in writing regarding the property’s selling price. Selling real property below market value can be considered misconduct, and the executor or administrator may be held liable for a surcharge. Therefore, having an attorney’s guidance is crucial to ensure the process is handled correctly and without upsetting the beneficiaries.

Real Property Transferred to an Heir: 

Real Property Transferred to an Heir

After estate proceedings conclude, the heirs become co-owners of the deceased’s real estate. In this scenario, all heirs must reach a consensus to sell the property. This situation can be particularly challenging when one co-heir resides in the property rent-free while others do not, leading to potential disputes about fairness.

If all heirs do not agree to sell the property, an heir may file an action for partition. Consulting with an attorney can be immensely helpful in this situation. The decision on whether all heirs must sell the property hinges on whether the property is still subject to estate proceedings or if it has already changed hands.

What Happens After Objections from All Heirs?

When property is still in probate, it isn’t necessary for all heirs to agree to the sale. Instead, the heirs must petition the court for approval to sell the property. Filing a suit for partition is another option, which allows the court to order the property’s sale. Nevertheless, consulting an attorney and adhering to the state’s county court’s instructions is advisable in these situations to navigate the legal complexities successfully.

Determining Ownership and Interests: 

Before selling a property, it’s crucial to determine ownership. This involves checking if there is an existing mortgage attached to the property. Additionally, understanding the hierarchy of heirs’ interests is vital. Not all heirs may have equal shares in the property, and the ownership interest can vary, depending on specific circumstances.

Selling Property Without Unanimous Beneficiary Approval: 

To execute the deceased’s wishes, an executor can sell property without the unanimous consent of all beneficiaries. However, beneficiaries should be informed throughout the process. When there’s a valid will, the estate executor, as approved by the judge, takes on the responsibility of overseeing the estate and making decisions in accordance with the deceased’s wishes.

The Role and Responsibilities of an Executor: 

A closer look at the essential functions of an executor:

  • Obtaining a copy of the will from the local courthouse.
  • Determining the type of probate required.
  • Representing the estate in court proceedings.
  • Compiling a comprehensive list of all assets.
  • Ensuring that all taxes and outstanding debts are settled.
  • Overseeing the estate’s settlement process.
  • Informing heirs about any open contest periods.

Selling Property at Fair Market Value: 

While property sales may sometimes occur at market value, especially when properties are in disrepair, it’s crucial to understand that the executor has the option to purchase the property. In such cases, all beneficiaries must agree to the terms of the sale, and the purchase must be made at fair market value.

Is It Beneficial to Keep Inherited Property? 

In some situations, it may be advantageous for heirs to hold onto inherited property. This could be due to various reasons, such as the property’s location in a promising area with potential for increased value over time. Heirs might also agree to manage the property collectively or explore renting it out or engaging in other business ventures. When making such decisions, it’s advisable to consult with an experienced real estate attorney to safeguard the interests of all parties involved.

Read Also:


Do all heirs need to agree to sell property during probate?

No, it is not necessary for all heirs to agree. The decision to sell the property lies with the executor or administrator, although consulting with heirs is advisable.

Can the executor sell the property without unanimous beneficiary approval?

Yes, the executor can sell the property without the unanimous consent of all beneficiaries, provided the will is valid and the judge has approved the executor’s role.

What happens if some heirs object to selling the property after estate proceedings conclude?

If objections persist, an heir can file a suit for partition, allowing the court to order the property’s sale.

How can heirs determine their ownership interests in the property?

It is important to understand that not all heirs may have equal shares in the property, and the ownership interest can vary depending on specific circumstances.

Is it beneficial to keep inherited property?

Keeping inherited property can be beneficial, especially if it’s in a promising location or if heirs have a clear agreement on how to manage or use the property. Consulting with a real estate attorney is advisable when making such decisions.


Inheriting property can be a complex process, especially when it comes to selling real estate. Navigating the legal intricacies while maintaining open communication among heirs is essential. Whether you’re an executor, administrator, or beneficiary, seeking guidance from legal professionals can help ensure that the property is managed and sold in a fair and lawful manner. If you have questions about selling or managing inherited property, consider consulting a qualified real estate attorney for expert advice and support.